Tony's Pizza New York Style

Absolutely amazing pizza! We are right across the street at Beecher Lodge and my husband and I decided we need a quick bite to eat. The large pizza was huge! Cheesy bread was absolutely perfect. The lady at the camera was absolutely amazing.

Okay, so this is my experience about this place and its amazing owner and his son. Me and my dad went to the beach, and halfway back to our Airbnb, he was telling me about ordering or getting pizza. On our way, we saw this pizza place. Once we parked, I realized they had a sign saying they were closing because they were sold out. I still decided to go in and ask if they were out of everything since I saw they also sold pasta and other things. I entered and asked if they were sold out on everything. Then I saw a huge receipt printout of all the orders they had received, so I realized how busy they must have been making those orders, and it was obvious they had a lot going on for me to even ask for a pizza. But then the owner told me they might have some left. He told me they had a pepperoni pizza and some garlic bread if I was okay with that. I told him that was fine and asked how much it was so I could pay for it, but he insisted that I take it for free. I knew I couldn’t and didn’t want to abuse such generosity, but he kept insisting that I take it for free. Before we left, he also told me about his other locations where I could get more food later on. I genuinely am not religious, but I think this was a sign from God or someone, as it was our first day in Saint Augustine. I am truly delighted by such kindness. So please, let’s help keep this business strong because they truly deserve it. Also the pizza is great super big and delicious I love that it was powered by tomato sauce , it’s own sauce that was hidden with the cheese layer was delicious and the garlic breads where soft

The service here is fantastic! Super friendly & very patient while we took forever to decide what we wanted. Our subs were great! They needed a few more spices though, but that's not the pizza joint's fault. I'm just picky. 😂 The food really was very flavorful. The really should start selling fettuccini alfredo though. That would be amazing! You should definitely check them out!

We were recommended to Tony’s Pizza by two different friends, and now we know why! I ordered the Super supreme and my hubby had the white pizza. The ingredients were incredibly fresh, the pizza dough was absolutely delicious, and the toppings were generously piled on. IYou can really taste the quality in every bite. Our daughter had the spaghetti and meatballs with garlic bread. It was very tasty. On top of that, the hospitality was top notch—warm, welcoming, and attentive. We’re already looking forward to our next visit!